Skip to main content

How to fix the Cleveland Browns by September

The Cleveland Browns are in the news for all the wrong reasons.

Combine on NFL Network


In advance of the draft, Marcus Mariota and others will look to showcase their skills at the combine (Feb. 17-23), only on NFL Network. **SCHEDULE**

Just days after the talented-but-troubled Josh Gordon was exiled into darkness with another year-long ban, first-round quarterback Johnny Manziel entered into self-imposed treatment. Thought to be the future of Cleveland's offense, it's unclear today if either player will ever live up to their potential. This front office inherited Gordon, but the drafting of Manziel falls into the lap of general manager Ray Farmer, now under significant fire after watching talented play-caller Kyle Shanahan walk out the door for a Falcons job he wanted more.

For all the progress made during a 7-9 season -- Cleveland's most wins in half a decade -- the optimism has been wiped away by the reality of utter chaos at the quarterback position and plenty of questions elsewhere.

With a full offseason ahead, here's what we'd do to fix up the Browns in time for September:

Three-pronged plan at quarterback

Pete Carroll's Seahawks weren't taken seriously until Russell Wilson emerged as a whirlwind under center. In the months leading up to the 2012 NFL Draft, Seattle was primed to enter the season with a dangerously over-hyped Matt Flynn battling milquetoast veteran Tarvaris Jackson for the starting quarterback job. By May, Flynn, T-Jax and Wilson were splitting snaps in a three-way competition that ignored Flynn's big contract or Wilson's status as an untouted rookie.

The Browns should take a similar approach.

Yes, it's a terrible year to find a passer -- the worst in eons -- but Cleveland should prioritize signal-callers with potentially high ceilings over stale retreads. Farmer has never voiced enthusiasm over paying Brian Hoyer more than backup money. If Hoyer walks -- and who could blame him? -- I'd use part of the team's roughly $50 million in cap space (third most in the league) to outbid the Texans for Ryan Mallett. He's a big-bodied, strong-armed passer with potential. He's imperfect, but Mallett's tape last season had its moments. The backup plan here would be Jake Locker or Matt Moore.

From there, Cleveland should use a mid-round draft pick to add another passer with NFL size -- Brett Hundley or Bryce Petty -- to give the team a contrast to the smallish Manziel. 

That brings us to Johnny Football, who -- ala Seattle -- would get a third of the work throughout the offseason to prove that his disastrous rookie debut is old news. Relying on Manziel for anything more is dangerous. The Browns must attack this position creatively through every possible channel.

Plan for life without Gordon

The clearest parallel for Gordon's misadventures is Justin Blackmon. Like the Jaguars, Cleveland has no reason to release a player who won't be paid this season and isn't taking up a roster sport.

Gordon is just 23, but it's fair to wonder if he'll ever take another NFL snap. After ignoring the receiver position in last year's draft, the Browns should consider using two or more of their 10 draft picks to flood the roster with talent. NFL Media's Lance Zierlein has West Virginia's Kevin White pegged to Cleveland at No. 12 overall, which isn't too early to address the need.

Re-signing veteran Miles Austin makes sense, while the free-agent market also offers Randall Cobb, Jeremy Maclin and Torrey Smith. Cleveland has the money to lure in one of these proven pass-catchers. As with Manziel, Gordon must be viewed as nothing more than a potential down-the-road luxury.

Keep the zone-blocking scheme

Browns fans should be encouraged to hear that new offensive coordinator John DeFilippo will stick with last year's zone-blocking scheme. Before Alex Mack was lost for the year, Cleveland's offensive line rivaled Dallas as one of the league's most fearsome fronts.

For all the heat he's taken, Farmer nailed the Joel Bitonio pick last May. The rookie guard was among the finest linemen in the NFL, helping Cleveland form an identity as a run-first team built for the AFC North. Adding more interior depth is critical, especially with Mack able to opt out of his contract after 2015.

Cleveland's early troubles upon returning to the NFL in 1999 are easy to dissect: One Browns front office after the next failed to build up the line, leaving a cast of mediocre quarterbacks to bleed. With three Pro Bowl-level talents up front, it makes sense for the Browns to stick with the zone scheme that scouts have spent a year finding matches for.

Re-sign Buster Skrine, add run-stuffers

Cornerback Justin Gilbert failed to deliver on his first-round pedigree. Touted as a problem child with questionable practice habits, the rookie -- like Manziel -- is a question mark heading into next season.

Coach Mike Pettine's defense hinges on strong corner play, something Skrine gave the Browns across from Joe Haden. Cleveland cannot afford to watch its own homegrown talent walk out the door. We expect Seahawks free-agent Byron Maxwell to make his way to Atlanta under Dan Quinn, but chasing after Antonio Cromartie -- who knows Pettine's defense well -- wouldn't be crazy, if the Browns are willing to deal with the cover man's quirkiness.

People forget that Cleveland's awful run defense was partly the product of losing so many players to injury. Still, the Browns are a candidate to use one of their two first-rounders on a massive run-stuffing machine -- never a poor decision in the AFC North.

Patience with Pettine at all costs

Outside of Cleveland, the last AFC North team to switch coaches was Baltimore in 2008.

The long night isn't over for the Browns. Facing both the AFC West and NFC West next season, Pettine will struggle to again reach seven wins. If he performs the way he did in 2014, though, he must be retained.

Blowing up the machine -- again -- ruins careers, derails the development of young players and asks established veterans to start over with new schemes, playbooks and teachers. The Browns must learn from the Steelers and Ravens -- and even the Bengals -- about the value of consistency.

Pettine has the feel of a talented young coach with a bright future. Joe Haden raved to us at the Super Bowl about Pettine's ability to relate with players and communicate his vision on a weekly basis. He handled last year's ups and downs with poise and should know that he is fully supported -- instead of looking over his shoulder.

The latest Around The NFL Podcast breaks down the top 25 free agents and reacts to the latest news. Find more Around The NFL content on NFL NOW.

This article has been reproduced in a new format and may be missing content or contain faulty links. Please use the Contact Us link in our site footer to report an issue.

Related Content